E-mentor logo
PL

For reviewers

The procedure of the reviewing process is in accordance with the recommendations of the Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education (described in ‘Good Practices in Reviewing Procedures in Science’ published in 2011). The journal applies the principles of publication ethics in accordance with the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics. Learn more here: ETHICS

The submitted manuscripts are subject to preliminary formal and content review (including thematic review). After the paper is evaluated as complying with the journal’s profile and fulfilling the requirements listed in the instructions for the authors, the chief editor appoints the reviewers who are specialists in a given field of knowledge that the paper is addressing.

The manuscript is reviewed confidently and anonymously ("double-blind" reviewing procedure), which means that the author and the reviewer do not know each other.

In exceptional cases, when keeping the author’s identity secret is not possible, the appointed reviewer cannot be in direct personal and business relationships and cannot have cooperated in scientific activity with the author in the course of the previous two years preceding the preparation of the review.

The reviewer prepares a written evaluation of the text in a proper form. The review consists of an unambiguous conclusion concerning the admission of the paper or its rejection or allowing a conditional acceptance for publication after introducing improvements suggested by the reviewer.

The author gets the information about the result of a reviewing process and introduces adequate changes if indicated. In the case of remarks the author does not agree with, he or she prepares an answer for the reviewer.

The editors make the final decision about the publication of the paper based on the analysis of the reviewer’s remarks and the quality of the final version provided by the author.

The manuscripts of a non-scientific character do not have to go through the reviewing process and are qualified for publication directly by the chief editor.

Appreciating the invaluable role of reviewers in the process of delivering the best quality papers, we wish to acknowledge the contributions of all reviewers who cooperated with "e-mentor" throughout 2023:

Nur Hidayah Che Ahmat, Godbless Akaighe, Nada Jehad Alsaleh, Maria Aluchna, Desmond Ayentimi, Jeremy Bachelor, Anna Baczko-Dombi, David Bawden, Dorota Bednarska-Olejniczak, Jan Beliczyński, András Benedek, Magdalena Borowska, Agata Borowska-Pietrzak, Jurica Bosna, Alexander Brem, Małgorzata Budzanowska-Drzewiecka, Emil Bukłaha, Urszula Bukowska, Paweł Cabała, Grażyna Cęcelek, Wojciech Cieśliński, Wojciech Czakon, Wojciech Marcin Czerski, Magdalena Daszkiewicz, Assunta Di Vaio, José Pedro Teixeira Domingues, Melinda Dooly, Wojciech Dyduch, Agnieszka Dziubińska, Agnieszka Ertman, Jan Fazlagić, Janina Filek, Robinson Fritz, Teresa Giza, Anna M. Górska, Konrad Grabiński, Grzegorz Grela, Monika Gzik, Aalaa Yaseen Hassan, Chad Hoggan, Sadiq Hussain, Marek Jarentowski, Sylwia Jaskuła-Korporowicz, Agnieszka Jeran, T. Bartosz Kalinowski, Joanna Kandzia, Wieslaw Karolak, Jarosław Karpacz, Kornélia Kiss, Małgorzata Klimka-Kołysko, Katarzyna Klimkiewicz, Agnieszka Klimska, Urszula Kłosiewicz-Górecka, Tomasz Knopik, Elżbieta Kolasińska, Paloma Korycińska, Alina Kozarkiewicz, Ewa Krok, Agota Kun, Jennifer Kunz, Sergo Kuruliszwili, Katie Louise Leggett, Krzysztof Leja, Marek Leszczyński, Aneta Lipińska, Paweł Lula, Joanna Łukasiewicz-Wieleba, Renata Marciniak, Czesław Mesjasz, Katarzyna Mikołajczyk, Danuta Morańska, Franciszek Mroczko, Rafał Mrówka, Marta Najda-Janoszka, Janusz Nowak, Don Olcott Jr., Victor Oltra, Ercan Özen, Antoni Pardała, Ryszard J. Pawlak, Beata Pawłowska, Anna Perkowska-Klejman, Gabriela Piechaczek-Ogierman, Anna Iwona Piotrowska, Robert Piszko, Jan Polcyn, Joanna Rabiega-Wisniewska, Ravichandran, Anna Rogala, Anna Rogozińska-Pawełczyk, Robert Romanowski, Marcin Roszkowski, Sergii Rudenko, Katarzyna Sanak-Kosmowska, Agnieszka Siedlecka, Łukasz Sienkiewicz, Elżbieta Skrzypek, Piotr Sliż, Katarzyna Smoter, Sławomir Sobczak, Monika Sońta, Elżbieta Sroka, Uglješa Stankov, Magdalena Stefańska, Andrzej Stępnikowski, Artur Strzelecki, Igor Stubelj, Arleta Szadziewska, Katarína Szarka, Monika Szczerbak, Jolanta Szempruch, Agata Szkiel, Jacek Szołtysek, Witold Szumowski, Izabela Ślęzak-Niedbalska, Bogusław Śliwerski, Joanna Tabor-Błażewicz, Preeti Tarkar, Jorge Tenorio Fernando, Dorina Tila, Łukasz Tomczyk, Małgorzata Trocka, Anna Trzcionka-Wieczorek, Marta Tutko, Mario Enrique Uribe Macías, Sławomir Wawak, Małgorzata Z. Wiśniewska, Piotr Wróbel, Magdalena Zajączkowska, Agnieszka Zakrzewska-Bielawska, Edyta Zawadzka, Robert Zenzerović, Agnieszka Żur.

Our reviewers represent almost 80 different institutions from 23 countries: Poland, Australia, Brazil, Colombia, Croatia, Germany, Hungary, India, Iraq, Italy, Japan, Malaysia, Portugal, Republic of South Africa, Saudi Arabia, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, The United Kingdom, The United States of America, Turkey, and Ukraine.